• Privacy policy
  • T&C’s
  • About Us
    • FAQ
    • Meet the Team
  • Contact us
  • Guest Content
TLE ONLINE SHOP!
  • TLE
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sport
  • Opinion
  • Elevenses
  • Entertainment
    • All Entertainment
    • Film
    • Lifestyle
      • Horoscopes
    • Lottery Results
      • Lotto
      • Thunderball
      • Set For Life
      • EuroMillions
  • Food
    • All Food
    • Recipes
  • Property
  • Travel
  • Tech/Auto
  • JOBS
No Result
View All Result
The London Economic
SUPPORT THE LONDON ECONOMIC
NEWSLETTER
  • TLE
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sport
  • Opinion
  • Elevenses
  • Entertainment
    • All Entertainment
    • Film
    • Lifestyle
      • Horoscopes
    • Lottery Results
      • Lotto
      • Thunderball
      • Set For Life
      • EuroMillions
  • Food
    • All Food
    • Recipes
  • Property
  • Travel
  • Tech/Auto
  • JOBS
No Result
View All Result
The London Economic
No Result
View All Result
Home Politics

Prime Minister’s plan to prorogue Parliament lawful, judge rules

Sitting at the Court of Session in Edinburgh, Lord Doherty said the decision can only be made by politicians and is not for the courts.

Joe Mellor by Joe Mellor
2019-09-04 11:21
in Politics
credit;PA

credit;PA

FacebookTwitterLinkedinEmailWhatsapp

A judge at the highest civil court in Scotland has found Boris Johnson’s planned prorogation of Parliament is lawful.

Legal action aimed at preventing the UK Government suspending Parliament ahead of the Brexit deadline of October 31 was considered at the Court of Session in Edinburgh on Tuesday.

It followed claims the Prime Minister wants to limit MPs’ scrutiny and their attempts to stop a no-deal Brexit.

Seems we have lost #Cherrycase to stop #prorogation at 1st instance. Judge rules court can’t review exercise of prerogative power to #prorogue. We thinks he’s erred in law on this point & others & will seek to appeal immediately #Brexit #StopTheCoup

— Joanna Cherry QC (@joannaccherry) September 4, 2019

Announcing his decision on Wednesday, Lord Doherty said choosing when to prorogue Parliament was for politicians and not the courts – but this will now be appealed against.

He said: “In my view the advice given in relation to the prorogation decision is a matter involving high policy and political judgement.

“This is political territory and decision-making, which cannot be measured by legal standards but only by political judgments.

“Accountability for the advice is to Parliament and ultimately the electorate and not to the courts.”

Lord Doherty added: “I do not accept the submission that the prorogation contravenes the rule of law and the claim is justiciable because of that.

“In my opinion there has been no contravention of the rule of law.

RelatedPosts

Steve Bray left bruised after being wrestled out of BBC debate on Brexit

Unearthed footage shows Gullis mocking trust fund parents

Door remains open for Britain to rejoin the EU, says Barnier

Union boss savages Rees-Mogg with understated sledge

“The power to prorogue is a prerogative power and the Prime Minister had the vires (powers) to advise the sovereign as to its exercise.”

The challenge from a cross-party group of 75 MPs and peers – led by SNP MP Joanna Cherry QC – argued the decision to prorogue Westminster to reduce time parliamentarians have to scrutinise legislation or attempt to prevent a no-deal Brexit is unlawful.

Soft suggestions from the Inner House (ie Scotland's highest court) that an appeal against today's decision might be heard on Thursday. (This morning's decision now slightly delayed beyond 10am).

— Jo Maugham (@JolyonMaugham) September 4, 2019

Jo Maugham QC was also among those supporting the case.

Speaking after the decision, he said: “The idea that if the Prime Minister suspends Parliament the courts can’t get involved loses some ugly demons.

“If he can do that for 34 days, why not 34 weeks or 34 months? Where does this political power end? It’s not the law as I understand it.

“Yesterday’s hearing was always going to be a bit of a pre-season friendly.

“We’re now focused on the Inner House, hopefully later this week, and then the Supreme Court on September 17.”

The appeal will be heard at the Inner House, which is the supreme civil court in Scotland.

In a hearing on Tuesday, it was revealed the Government appeared to consider suspending Parliament as early as mid-August.

This was two weeks before publicly announcing the move and despite Mr Johnson’s spokesman then claiming any suggestion of prorogation was “entirely false”.

A note dated August 15 from Nickki da Costa, a former director of legislative
affairs at Number 10 – which was seen by Mr Johnson and his adviser Dominic Cummings – asked whether an approach should be made to prorogue Parliament, between September 9 and October 14.

A note of “yes” was written on the document, the Court of Session in Edinburgh heard.

Aiden O’Neill QC, representing the cross-party parliamentarians, said: “One presumes this was a document sent in the red box to the Prime Minister to be read at his leisure.”

The Queen met the Privy Council on August 28 to approve the move.

Mr O’Neill described Mr Johnson as having a record that was “characterised by incontinent mendacity, an unwillingness or inability to speak the truth”.

Responding for the Government, David Johnston QC, said: “The proper forum for these matters to be scrutinised is the political forum.

“Those who make decisions that don’t go down well in the political forum will
be held to account there – either in Parliament or, ultimately, by the electorate.”

Tories could suffer heavy losses in Scotland in snap election, poll suggests

Content Protection by DMCA.com

Since you are here

Since you are here, we wanted to ask for your help.

Journalism in Britain is under threat. The government is becoming increasingly authoritarian and our media is run by a handful of billionaires, most of whom reside overseas and all of them have strong political allegiances and financial motivations.

Our mission is to hold the powerful to account. It is vital that free media is allowed to exist to expose hypocrisy, corruption, wrongdoing and abuse of power. But we can't do it without you.

If you can afford to contribute a small donation to the site it will help us to continue our work in the best interests of the public. We only ask you to donate what you can afford, with an option to cancel your subscription at any point.

To donate or subscribe to The London Economic, click here.

The TLE shop is also now open, with all profits going to supporting our work.

The shop can be found here.

You can also SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER .

Subscribe to our Newsletter

View our  Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions

Trending on TLE

  • All
  • trending
Abdollah

‘Rescue us’: Afghan teacher begs UK to help him escape Taliban

CHOMSKY: “If Corbyn had been elected, Britain would be pursuing a much more sane course”

What If We Got Rid Of Prisons?

More from TLE

PM apologises for not wearing a mask on hospital visit

Toddlers among latest migrants crossing Channel days after tragedy

Ofcom TV figures confirm that the way we consume media has “fundamentally changed”

BBC News presenter taken off air following ‘gleeful’ reaction to Johnson pulling out of Tory leadership race

Parts of the Amazon thought uninhabited were actually home to up to a million people

Thunderball Results for Wednesday 24 November 2021 Tonight’s winning numbers

Surrey bar slammed for hosting under 18’s Valentine’s event called ‘Pop Ya Cherry’

In pictures: Ealing Soup Kitchen rises to the challenge of Covid-19

Perfectly Crispy Tuna Fishcakes

Shortage of Covid tests ahead of NYE as NHS setting up ‘surge hubs’ & goes on ‘war footing’

JOBS

FIND MORE JOBS

About Us

TheLondonEconomic.com – Open, accessible and accountable news, sport, culture and lifestyle.

Read more

Contact

Editorial enquiries, please contact: [email protected]

Commercial enquiries, please contact: [email protected]

Address

The London Economic Newspaper Limited t/a TLE
Company number 09221879
International House,
24 Holborn Viaduct,
London EC1A 2BN,
United Kingdom

SUPPORT

We do not charge or put articles behind a paywall. If you can, please show your appreciation for our free content by donating whatever you think is fair to help keep TLE growing and support real, independent, investigative journalism.

DONATE & SUPPORT

© 2019 thelondoneconomic.com - TLE, International House, 24 Holborn Viaduct, London EC1A 2BN. All Rights Reserved.




No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Food
  • Travel
  • JOBS
  • More…
    • Elevenses
    • Opinion
    • Property
    • Tech & Auto
  • About Us
    • Meet the Team
    • Privacy policy
  • Contact us

© 2019 thelondoneconomic.com - TLE, International House, 24 Holborn Viaduct, London EC1A 2BN. All Rights Reserved.