Economic growth is an unnecessary evil, Jacinda Ardern is right to deprioritise it

In 2012, writing as a lone economics blogger, I put forward a case for why countries should ditch economic growth as a political priority.

Long revered as a stalwart of a capitalist society the need to grow has come to overshadow everything else. We prioritise it over our personal health, we prioritise it over the health of the planet and we prioritise it over our happiness.

But given that the function of any economy is to provide an environment of subsistence, that could be little short-sighted.

Economist Kenneth Boulding once said that we eat in order to achieve the state of being well-fed, and moving our jaws is simply the ‘cost’ of getting there. We would therefore be mistaken to focus our attention on the act of chewing as the desired end-state when it is simply the price we pay to become fed.

But as long as growth is the target of our economic systems people will continue to focus on chewing, which is neither a sustainable nor desirable trait of an economy.

Which is why I welcomed news that New Zealand’s Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has put out a national budget where spending is dictated by what best encourages the “well-being” of citizens, rather than focussing on traditional bottom-line measures like productivity and economic growth.

The government will put an emphasis on goals like community and cultural connection and equity in well-being across generations in what has been described as a “game-changing event” by LSE professor Richard Layard.

As part of the framework Ardern has set aside more than $200 million to bolster services for victims of domestic and sexual violence and included a promise to provide housing for the homeless population.

New guidance on policy suggests all new spending must advance one of five government priorities: improving mental health, reducing child poverty, addressing the inequalities faced by indigenous Maori and Pacific islands people, thriving in a digital age, and transitioning to a low-emission, sustainable economy.

Take a look at the biggest problems faced world-wide and you would be hard pushed to find examples that are more grave than the ones set out in Ardern’s provisional proposals. Rising inequality, a mental health crisis and climate change are all significant threats, but as long as other major economies prioritise economic growth over wellbeing New Zealand may become a lone wolf trapped in an increasingly hungry bear pit.

Related Posts

Switzerland to re-run referendum because “voters were not given full information”
Theresa May under pressure over blocking security services probe into Arron Banks Brexit campaign millions
The British Government has ruined my life

7 Responses

  1. Terre Nash

    Excellent piece by Jack Peat. (Economic growth is an unnecessary evil, Jacinda Ardern is right to deprioritise it). Watch my award-winning feature documentary, “Who’s Counting? Marilyn Waring on Sex, Lies and Global Economics” on New Zealand economist Marilyn Waring, to get an in-depth understanding of these ideas (for free on-line):

  2. Martin

    With all due respect to Mrs. Ardern, let’s not forget that this is not just her work, nor that of Labour. In fact, if the Greens weren’t in coalition, I doubt we’d have come this far…

  3. J Prakash

    I have been blogging for sometime that the whole economic doctrine has become irrelevant today. To me Capitalism is dead. The world has moved to a perennial deflation mode. No economist of the world has realised this. I have also given my reasoning for my hypothesis. Would appreciate your comments
    My blogs can be read from my website Have given links to some of them below.

    Prakash Jagannathan
    5:08 PM (14 minutes ago)
    to me

Leave a Reply