By Nick Figgis A seriously inconvenient truth, but it might be time we face it.

Kuhn and Anderson’s thrilling documentary is a rare gem in environmental film – it poses questions and actually answers them. I watched most of Cowspiracy muttering expletives under my breath. For a meat and dairy eater, whose girlfriend has been known to ask if I “want some toast with my butter,” it’s an eye opener but not in the way you might expect.

Fear not, this is no attempt to shock and shame you into renouncing sin by exposing you to grainy, covert footage of sickly chickens being sucked into a giant mincer. To start with it is a masterclass in documentary film making. Deft pacing, a dry sense of humour and a self-effacing protagonist make it eminently watchable. There’s an engaging simplicity to the narrative and data presentation which is supported by simple but beautiful cinematography.

Ok, so that’s the easy stuff. Now for the inconvenient bit. Between bouts of squirming, effing and blinding (see – men can multi task!) I had to wonder; how do you convince people to watch a film with a message most of them are going to find discomforting?

If you are a reasonably informed person, you’re probably aware of the overwhelming evidence in support of human caused climate change. If you’ve got kids, or nephews and nieces you’ve probably felt the guilt of the concerned but inactive. Or maybe you’ve had an epiphany and decided to take action. Maybe your average day starts with a super short shower. You switch the water off while lathering up and you resist the temptation to stand for an extra ten minutes under an almost scalding stream, singing “I am what I am” while inspecting your bits.

That is a luxury we can no longer afford. Your bits do look snug, one might even say smug, squeezed into your nifty little cycling onesie, and you have a satisfied spring in your step as you deposit three separate bags of rubbish in full view of your less conscientious neighbours. One bag for general waste (regrettable but at least it’s only a small one), one for food (what do they do with the food one?), and one with well washed recyclables (because you have to wash before you squash, you know). You take no prisoners in your daily battle with the Chelsea tractor morons on the way to work, they are after all murdering your unborn children. Then you pop into your favourite independent, organic, fair trade coffee place to grab one of their scrummy free range bacon sarnies… Sorry? You do what?! Right, well you may as well have slept under a full flowing power shower, burned your rubbish in your front garden and driven to work in an actual tractor.

Ok, so I haven’t fact checked this statement. Fortunately, Anderson’s calculations are more considered. Here are some tasters: Raising Cattle uses more greenhouse gasses (18%) than all cars, trucks, trains, ships and planes combined (13%) when you factor in methane emissions. Yes, that’s cow farts. According to NASA Methane has a global warming power 86 times that of CO2. Livestock production is the leading cause of species extinction, deforestation, greenhouse gas emissions, water shortage and ocean destruction on the planet today.

The good news is Anderson doesn’t spend the film abusing meat eaters. Of course he turns his guns on giant livestock corporations, but more surprisingly, it’s our favourite environmental agencies who take most of the flak for failing to address the issue. Seeing eco CEO’s on the rack is weirdly entertaining, but it’s also disturbing, there genuinely does seem to be a conspiracy of silence around this issue. If you want to experience despair there are plenty of options nowadays.

You could read George Monbiot’s column when he’s on a downer or the latest UN report on climate change, or you could turn to the plethora of films on the subject. The trouble with many of these films is the feel good bit at the end. Perhaps, like me you find graphics of super space aged planes running on positive vibes or crowds of people dumping money outside banks and spontaneously agreeing to create utopia unconvincing?

This film is different. There is some really uplifting, positive stuff at the end but more importantly, there’s a clear answer to the questions posed. It remains to be seen whether we are ready to hear that answer. We’re a strange bunch us 21st centurions. Our not too distant ancestors underwent beatings, massacres, imprisonment and forced feedings to achieve universal suffrage, our grandparents signed up in their millions to fight fascism.

But I’ve a feeling most people will block their ears to this inconvenient truth, we are so wedded to instant gratification. Though perhaps I should take a leaf out of the Anderson/Kuhn book and end on a positive note. This is Dr William Tuttle from the film: If we didn’t raise livestock “we wouldn’t have to devote all this land to growing grains… to feed to them… then the forests could come back, wild life could come back, the oceans would[regenerate], rivers would run clean again, the air would come back, our health would return”. This notion that what we have to do is retreat, stand back and watch nature regenerate, and that this would lead to a planet not just being sustained but actually thriving and teaming with natural wonders, has to be one of the most inspiring ideas any human can get hold of.

9 Responses

  1. Catia

    I did change my lifestyle after learning the truth, I became 100% vegan, nothing that comes from animals or has been tested on them or causes their suffering enters my life. I feel a better person for it, I, for the first time feel more humane, I am looking after this planet and all the wonderful creatures that we share it with. If you need the push to fully convert yourself to veganism, then I recommend watching Cowspiracy first and then Earthlings. Once the connection is made, nothing ever will be the same again.

  2. Paula

    Once you truly understand the truth, once you open your eyes, there’s no way you are looking at your shopping list in the same way again. This is a matter of education. Let’s spread facts, knowledge and science, so with every generation the task will be easier. We can and must claim this world back from Corporations.

  3. Macca

    Sounds reasonable, but if I sold my 4×4, what would I tow the damn boat with? My green creds are lecric bike an solar panels…can I simply relax?

  4. Cbarr

    “If you’ve got kids, or nephews and nieces you’ve probably felt the guilt of the concerned but inactive.”

    This statement makes my blood boil. Shouldn’t caring about climate change be something that’s not contingent on whether it might affect people you love? The motivation is upside down, you should care because the way the human race currently behaves pays f!ck all regard to the other organisms we share our planet with, there are plenty more of them, and most have been quietly eking out an existence long before we showed up and ruined everything. Egocentric worldview.

  5. CK

    There is a biased view presented in Cowspiracy. Factory farming and all that supports it is a travesty for people, the soil and the animals. However, cattle grazed on grass with rotational grazing are restorative to the soil, water cycle, and ecological diversity. Kip Anderson looks very clearly at what has been out of balance but leaves out this important distinction. Yes we need to quit cutting down rainforests to graze cattle. Yes we need to quit feeding cattle corn and soy and growing these products in order to keep animals in forms of bondage. And we need to restore our grasslands that used to support millions of bison. There is huge carbon sequestration to be had from this. Please read Courtney White, author and significant environmentalist who began The Quivira Coalition. Restoring our soil is primary to our collective well-being and Kip Anderson completely misses this in his presentation.

  6. Hi. I see that you don’t update your page too often. I know that writing posts
    is boring and time consuming. But did you know that there is a tool that allows you to
    create new posts using existing content (from article directories or other pages from your niche)?
    And it does it very well. The new posts are unique
    and pass the copyscape test. You should try miftolo’s tools

Leave a Reply