The icy worlds of Europa and Enceladus could never be habitable – because they suffer from either extreme hot or cold.
NASA has said the mysterious moons of Jupiter and Saturn respectively could one day be home to humans.
But scientist said the moons swing from a “icehouse” to “hothouse” without a “goldilocks” period when conditions are just right for life to thrive.
The finding could have implications for the search for extra-terrestrial life as they are believed to be the likeliest places in the solar system to find it.
Unlike the deserts of Mars they are both covered by oceans.
The new global climate model shows some planets and moons like Europa and Enceladus change abruptly from extreme cold to extreme heat as their host star brightens – without passing through a habitable phase.
It had been hoped such worlds in our Solar System – and those outside known as exoplanets – could become habitable after their ice cover melts.
But these small worlds lack the geological processes of larger planets like Earth because they lose their heat faster.
The evolution of their climate depends solely on the energy received from the host star.
The computer simulation found Europa and Enceladus don’t have our planet’s active carbon cycle – which allowed it to recover from its snowball state to a perfect environment for life to thrive.
Without atmospheric greenhouse gases to help warm the moon or planet the energy required to melt the ice is so high once it melts it goes straight a greenhouse state.
The study published in Nature Geoscience showed the oceans vaporise making water disappear – resulting in a world unable to support life as we know it.
Professor Jun Yang, of Peking University in Beijing, said: “Ongoing and future space missions aim to identify potentially habitable planets in our Solar System and beyond.
“Planetary habitability is determined not only by a planet’s current stellar insolation and atmospheric properties but also by the evolutionary history of its climate.
“It has been suggested that icy planets and moons become habitable after their initial ice shield melts as their host stars brighten.
“Here we show from global climate model simulations that a habitable state is not achieved in the climatic evolution of those icy planets and moons that possess an inactive carbonate-silicate cycle and low concentrations of greenhouse gases.
“Examples for such planetary bodies are the icy moons Europa and Enceladus, and certain icy exoplanets.”
Carbon has been critical for the emergence of life and the regulation of our climate through the carbon-silicate cycle.
It’s been debated how carbon-rich chemistry will affect the habitability of Europa and Enceladus.
Prof Yang said: “We find the stellar radiation required to overcome a planet’s initial snowball state are so large that they lead to significant water loss and preclude a habitable planet.
“Specifically, they exceed the moist greenhouse limit, at which water vapour accumulates at high altitudes where it can readily escape, or the runaway greenhouse limit, at which the strength of the greenhouse increases until the oceans boil away.
“We suggest that some icy planetary bodies may transition directly to a moist or runaway greenhouse without passing through a habitable Earth-like state.”
He added: “Icy worlds are common in the Solar System – such as Europa, Enceladus, Ganymede and early Earth and plausibly also in extrasolar systems.”
Ganymede is Jupiter’s largest moon but has been said to have less potential for life because its oceans lacks a hydrothermal system.
“A fundamental question is: would such icy planets and moons become habitable once their ice cover melts?”
Earth has been geologically active throughout its history and the volcanic emission of greenhouse gases and weathering processes have acted to warm and stabilise the climate
Prof Yang said: “Europa and Enceladus will have no habitable period.
“We emphasise our conclusion applies to planets that have an inactive carbonate-silicate cycle and low concentrations of greenhouse gases.”
He explained: “The post-snowball Earth is hot but it is in neither a runaway nor a moist greenhouse state.
“This is because the solar flux is much lower than the runaway greenhouse limit and the high level of CO2 acts to cool the upper atmosphere and thereby decrease the water concentration there.”
Planetary scientist Prof Andrew Ingersoll, of California Institute of Technology in Pasadena who reviewed the findings for the journal, said: “Making an icy planet habitable is not as simple as melting its ice: many icy bodies swing from too cold to too hot – by-passing just right.”
Earlier this year NASA said life could be thriving in warm underground seas on Enceladus – even though it’s 887 million miles away from the Sun.
Its Cassini spacecraft picked up the first evidence of chemical reactions capable of supporting microbes.
Since you’re here …
We do not charge or put articles behind a paywall. If you can, please show your appreciation for our free content by donating whatever you think is fair to help keep TLE growing.
Every penny we collect from donations supports vital investigative and independent journalism. You can also help us grow by inviting your friends to follow us on social media.